HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS’ DIFFICULTIES
IN SOLVING PROBLEMS IN PHYSICS
Luzviminda M. Panes
THE PROBLEM
This study sought to
determine the difficulties of fourth year high school students in solving problems
in Physics.
METHODOLOGY
This study
is a diagnostic-illuminative type. It was intended to reveal conceptual or procedural errors
that students commit in solving word problems in high school Physics. To achieve this end, the researcher
used the survey method of gathering information. In this method, all fourth year students of the two
schools, SSPSC Tagbina and SSPSC Lianga, were asked to respond to a Diagnostic Test prepared by the
author.
The test
was divided into 4 levels, level 1, understanding what is asked in the problems that measure the
reading comprehension skills of students; Level 2, measuring the student’s skills in translating unknown into mathematical expression; and level 3 measuring the student’s skills in formulating
mathematical equation that expresses the relation of he variables in the problem;
lastly, in Level 4, solving problems involving linear equation, quadratic and
exponential equation.
The statistical
tools used in analyzing the data were means and z-test.
FINDINGS
-
The study found out that most students understood what is asked in the
problem. The results revealed that out of 130 students who took the diagnostic
test, there were 76 students who passed level 1 question.
-
In level 2 questions, students found difficulty in translating unknown
into mathematical expression. There were only 44 students out of 130 who passed.
-
In formulating mathematical equation that expresses the relation of
the variables in the problem for level 3 questions, many students did not answer
correctly and only 53 students passed this level.
-
In level 4, students found it most difficult in solving problems which
consisted of three different types of worded problems, linear equation, quadratic
equation and exponential equation problems. The results of the test revealed
that most of the students found it most difficult in solving worded problems
involving quadratic equation and exponential equation. Out of 130 students, 38 passed this level.
-
The study also found out that there was a significant difference between
the proportion of students who passed level 1, level 3 and level 4 question of
SSPSC-Tagbina Campus and the proportion of students who passed level 1 , level
3, and level 4 questions. For the level 2 question, there was no significant
difference between the proportions.
CONCLUSIONS
From the above findings, the following conclusions were drawn:
-
The students were not prepared or equipped to take Physics subject.
They lacked mathematical skillswhich are needed in solving worded problems.
-
Many students could not solve worded problem because they could not
translate unknown into mathematical expression and formulate mathematical equation
that expresses the relation of the variables in the problem.
-
The students found it most difficult in solving worded problems involving
quadratic and exponential equations.The
results also indicated that the higher the level of questions the more is the increase of the level of difficulty.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Based on the findings the recommendations are prescribed:
-
The findings of the study may be made known to students, teachers of
Physics, teachers in mathematics, teachers in English, principals, supervisors
for their information and guidance.
-
Although there was a greater number of students who passed level 1 questions,
it is then, suggested that there must be a remedial class for English subjects,
because there was still a proportion of the students who could not comprehend
the problems thoroughly.
-
To the second year mathematics teachers, it is suggested that they give
more emphasis on mathematics sentences, inequalities, as to provide students
basic knowledge in translating into mathematical expression in preparation for
solving worded problems. Furthermore, it is also suggested that they give equal
weight of timed in taking up problems with the following types: linear equations, quadratic equations
and exponential expression.
-
It is recommended that the Physics teacher spend more time, effort,
intellect and patience in teaching the subject.
-
This study is confined to its own limitations; it is therefore recommended
that further researches that involve all the topics in fourth year high school
physics curriculum be undertaken
-
The researcher recommends further study to find out if there is a significant
difference in the students’ performance in physics between male and female.
-
Further study be conducted to find out if the educational attainment
of parents is one of the factors that affect students’ performance.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books
Kelly, William A. Educational Psychology. Philippines: Edca Publishing
and Distributing Corporation,1993.
Salmorin, Lolita M. et. al. Science and technology Physics. Quezon City:
Abida Publishing House, Inc.1995.Unpublished Materials
Calugan, Bangasan. “Percieved Difficulties of senior Physics
Students in the Secondary Schools.” Thesis. St. Louis University, Baguio
City. Nov. 1988.
Cristobal, Ruby. “Government
bares Science Education Plan for 2001-2005” S&T POST Vol .XVII No.12 Dec.
2001, 1.
Geronimo, Marites. “The
Effects of Integration of Mathematics and Physics Concepts on the Physics Achievement
of Fourth Year high school students of Isabela National High School”. Thesis.
Philippines Normal University Graduate College, Manila, 1988.
Moises, Meden. “
The effects of Mathematics Review on the Learning of High School Chemistry and in Problem
Solving”. Thesis. Capiz National High School. Capiz. Roxas City, 1994
Navarro, Murray Saturnino Fernando. “Effects
of mathematical Support to the CONSTEL telecourse in Physics Teachers Learning
and Lesson Presentation”. Dissertation. U.P. College of Education,
Diliman, Quezon City, 1998
Ramones, Marichita. “Factors
Related to Students’ Difficulties in Solving Problems in High School in Physics”.
Thesis. University of the Philippines College of Education. Diliman, Quezon
City
Su, Gregoria T. “ Effects
of Starter – Based Experiment Approach in Physics: Performance and Values Development”.
Unpublished Master’s Thesis, Cebu Normal University, 1999.
Internet Source
Blosser, Patricia. “ Teaching Problem Solving-Secondary School
Science”. U.S., Educational Resources Information Center, ERIC/SMEAC
Science Education Digest No. 2 ED 309049, 1988.
Britz, Joan. “Problem Solving in Early Childhood Classrooms”
U.S. Educational Resources Information Center, ERIC Digest ED 355040, 1993.
Campione, J.C., A. L. Brown, and M.L. Connell. “Metacognition:
On the Importance what you are doing” In R.I. Charles & E. A. Siler
(Eds), The Teaching Assessing of Mathematical Problem Solving . Reston, VA:
Lawrence Erlbaum, national Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 1988.
Charles, R. I., F. K. Lester, and P. O’Daffer. How to Evaluate
Progress in Problems Solving. Reston, Virginia: national Council of Teachers
of Mathematics, 1987.
Geban, Omer., Askar, Petek., Ozkan, Ilker. “
Effects of computer Simulations and Problems-Solving Approaches on High School
Students”. Journal of Education Research. Vol. 86 no. 1 (Sept./Oct.
1992).
Koch, Adina., Eckstein, Shulamith. “Skills
Needed for Reading Comprehension of Physics Texts and Their relation to Problem-Solving
Ability”. Journal of Research Science Teaching, 32, no. 6 (1995). 613-28.
Lankard, Bettina. “Integrating
Science and Math in Vocational Education”. U.S., Educational Resources information
Center, ERIC Digest ED 355456, 1992
Means, Gladys. “ The influence on Problem-Solving Ability of
Following an Efficient Model”. The Journal of Educational Research,
62, no. 3 (Nov. 1965).
Piemonte, Charles, “The
Crusade for Problem Solving in Mathematics Education”. Condensed Curriculum Review,
Vol. XX (June 1981), 220-223.
Russell, Michael., Chiapetta, Eugene. “The
Effects of a Problem Solving on the Achievement of Earth Science Students”.
Journal of Research in Science Teaching. 18. no. 4 (1981). 295-01.
Slife, Brent D. et. al. Cook, Ruth. “Development
Skills in Solving Problem”. How to build on Natural tendency. Vol. XXI (Sept. 1985) 5-13.
Trismen. D.A. “Hintss:
An Aid to Diagnosis in Mathematical Problem Solving” Journal for Research in Mathematics
Education. Vol 19 (1988). 358-361.
Wilson, James W, Maria L. Fernandez, and Nelda Hadaway. Mathematical
Problem Solving. http://jwilson.coe.uga.edu/emt725/PSsyn/PSsyn.html
Wood Terry., Sellers, Patricia. “
Deepening the Analysis: Longitudinal Assessment of a Problem-Centered Mathematics
Program”. Journal for Research in mathematics Education. 28, no. 2
(1997). 163-164.
|